You've struck a nerve here, GlassyGreen. The questions you've asked are the questions most people have when they decide to do their estate planning; i.e., who should be the executor of my estate, the trustee of my living trust, and the agent (attorney-in-fact) under my durable power of attorney and health care directives?
These positions are so-called "fiduciary" positions because the people who serve in these positions are representing the interests of other people, not themselves. As such, the law holds these "fiduciaries" to a high standard in carrying out their responsibilities and duties.
When pressed to make a decision regarding the appointment of fiduciaries under their estate plan, most individuals will choose individuals whom they know and have a high degree of confidence in. The logical choices that come to mind for most individuals are a spouse and/or children, then other close relatives, then someone in a professional relationship to that individual; i.e., an attorney, an accountant, a business associate, etc. In some cases, there may not be a suitable individual to serve in any fiduciary position. In that case, a bank or trust company may be a good option, although most banks and trust companies have minimum requirements for the value of trust or estate assets before they will agree to serve as a trustee or executor. For more detailed information concerning the selecting of trustees (and other fiduciaries), see our article entitled, "
Selecting Trustees."
Still, if - as you suggest - there really is no logical or seemingly appropriate choice for an individual to serve as a fiduciary, and a bank or trust company is not a viable option either, then what do you do?
If the fiduciary position is the executor under your will, you really should designate someone under your will because, if you don't, then the probate court will appoint someone as the administrator of your estate. And, that someone will be an attorney that you probably never knew during your lifetime and your beneficiaries may not know as well. So, it's incumbent upon you to make every effort to find someone whom you believe will carry out your wishes after you're gone.
As to your living trust, the designation of a successor trustee should not that difficult (although I know it generally is). The key, I believe, is to focus on the objective of the trust. For example, if you have the trust solely to avoid probate and the assets will be distributed outright to your designated beneficiaries upon your death, then one or more of your designated beneficiaries are the logical people to serve as trustees - after all, it's going to be their property once you're gone, so they have the most interest in preserving your property and making sure that it gets to them with the least amount of delay and expense.
One or more of those beneficiaries should also be an ideal candidate to serve as successor trustee in the event you should become incapacitated, although you may decide that an independent trustee (such an attorney or an accountant) would be better. If you are inclined to think that an independent trustee is best for you, then now would be the time to develop a relationship with an experienced and highly-regarded attorney in your local area. Don't go on the cheap here. If you want your attorney to be your trustee (and executor), don't look for the lowest cost to get your estate planning documents prepared. Look, instead, for the integrity and reputation and experience of the attorney.
One other point: You indicated that your trust is rather small and consists only of the death benefits under life insurance policies on your life. Life Insurance death benefits do not pass through probate and they are not available to you during your lifetime. So, unless the trust is necessary to hold the death benefits for minor children, there is no reason for a living trust. You could simply name the beneficiaries directly under the life insurance policies.
If, however, there are minor children who are the beneficiaries of the life insurance policies, then the parents and/or legal guardians of those children are the logical individuals to serve as the trustee or trustees.
I will address the naming of fiduciaries under a power of attorney and health care directives in another post to follow.